Bake Me A Wish

303 5th Avenue, STE 2001, 10016, New York
image
3.20
Based on 20 Reviews

5

45.00%

4

0.00%

3

20.00%

2

0.00%

1

35.00%
About Bake Me A Wish

For over 10 years, Bake Me A Wish! has been delivering gourmet quality cakes nationwide in time for our customer's special occasions, including birthdays, anniversaries, Valentines, Mother's Day - you name it! Birthday Cakes are our specialty, and we have over 25 flavors and styles of cake to choose from! Remember the excitement you felt as a child when your birthday cake is brought into the room for your special wish? As we get older, we often look over the chance to indulge ourselves, if only for one day a year, to make it a very special day. Bake Me A Wish! allows fiends and families to recreate that experience and send a delicious cake to their loved one and have it arrive on their birthday - guaranteed!

Tags
Contact Info

You need to Login first to submit your review.

image
Lisa Perry
GB

Do NOT waste your money! I ordered a gluten-free red velvet cake for my daughter's birthday. The wrong cake was shipped and I promptly called to have it replaced. I was told it would arrive the next day but it did not. It was too late to find another baker on a Saturday evening who could replace the cake and my daughter went without a cake for her birthday. The company was defensive, unapologetic, and refused to refund the full amount of the order as I had added the candles, a teddy bear, and a cookie tower. After all of the heartache this experience caused my family, I believe a full refund is the least they could do. The food items that did arrive were dry and incredibly small. I never leave reviews but I hope to save someone from having the same horrendous experience that I had.

image
N Ken
GB

Mushy inedible pie We ordered lemon meringue pie and with shipping cost over $80. When it defrosted it was complete mush and the meringue wilted. What a disappointment and useless for Thanksgiving. It was a gift for my father who is in long term care so truly sad. Update: the company refunded me completely. Well done! Updated from 1 to 3 stars

image
Cake Connoisseur
GB

I ordered the coconut creme cake again… I ordered the coconut creme cake again this year for my sister-in-law's birthday because she and my brother enjoyed the made from scratch ingredients of the light, fluffy texture of the cake and the delicious taste of the creme frosting! The delivery was key especially last year during the pandemic. I only wish the cake price was below $ 30.00 instead of $ 52.00, not including shipping!

image
Lianne Hart
GB

Dry cake, crumbled into saw dust. Probably sat in freeze for months. ordered the sample cakes for my birthday. thought it'd be fun to send myself some cake... Cake was awful. dry and crumbled up mess. Clearly have been sitting in a freezer for months. Nothing separated the different cakes from each other, they literally were all the same "cookies and cream" has maybe a little white chocolate swirl on top but it literally was just a chocolate cake, the chocolate torte was different only because it had frosting but it didn't save the fact that the cake just crumbled into sawdust when you cut it. the double chocolate... couldn't figure out what was different from it.. just another chocolate cake. didn't bother trying to the carrot since I hate carrot cake and I didn't have an option to exchange it. for the cost of the cakes + shipping. I'll never buy from them again. happy birthday to me.

image
Barbara in Nottingham
GB

Birthday cakes I had 4 cup cakes baked for a birthday surprise. They were delicious and were presented so nice in a sturdy box showing "happy birthday ". The icing wasn't too sweet-- just perfect. Thank you

We may use cookies or any other tracking technologies when you visit our website, including any other media form, mobile website, or mobile application related or connected to help customize the Site and improve your experience. learn more

Allow