Filets are excellent Filets are excellent. I would order the smaller size next time as the large ones are difficult to cook and are meant for two people (at least people with larger appetites than me).

This is one of the easiest reviews ever This is one of the easiest reviews I’ve ever written. These steaks are by far the best I’ve ever ordered, and I’ve tried all the other mail order steak companies. Not that the others are not good, but I think Mr. Steak is better. They don’t have all they other food options like the other companies, their focus is steak, and it shows in the quality you get. My new go-to steak company.

Great experience so far ordering went smoothly. called when shipment was not going to arrive on second day. The young lady I spoke with was very friendly and courteous and told me what I was to do when shipment arrived in order to make sure the product was safe. She is a good representative for the company. The shipment arrived late the next day but was safe. If the products taste as good as they look this is a fine company.

Great Ribeye So far, we’ve only had the 12 oz ribeye, which was delicious. I was surprised, however, to see that the thickness was not uniform across the steak. It tapered noticeably from one end to the other, preventing an even cook.

Order damaged When I got my order, Fed Ex called as the package had broke open due to the ice melting. Once received, the steak packages were torn and the meat was exposed. I sent pictured. I repackaged them and re-froze them. The steaks are very good, but the delivery process was clearly flawed. Thank you,