What was pictured and described was not… What was pictured and described was not what was sent. I ordered a 1972 bottle of scotch and paid $125 for it, what I received was a plastic jug of scotch that you can buy in any liquor store today for $25. They said refused my complaint saying that's what I ordered. I blame myself, should have looked at the reviews.

Ordered a hard to find 50y old whiskey… I ordered a hard to find 50y old whiskey. What I liked about them - Responded to questions within 24h - Delivered the exact item I ordered w/o substitutions What I did not like - Took all the money up front, I suspect this is because they buy it in the UK and have folks bring it over. So they need the money to buy first. - Took 45d to deliver - No progress update in between - Price is much higher than UK stores (but they do not ship to the US) Summary Use them for hard to find/unique items definitely not for items you can get at Bevmo or TotalWine. Their prices are much higher - 3x the price in the UK - but I suspect they have folks bring them here. So use only for special occasions.

Fake Inventory on website Cask Cartel posts bottles on their website that they do not have. There is no warning whatsoever that you are about to order something out of stock. They simply take the order, take your money, and go attempt to procure it after the sale... which can take weeks to months. They do not bother notifying you of anything in the meantime. Bottom line: If you order from cask cartel, you are gambling on when you will get it and possibly never. I tried multiple times. One arrived on time and one was 3 weeks late. This next one is 3 weeks late and not yet arrived.

Ripoff Their business model is to place very high prices on single bottle quantity hoping to fool buyers. Unfortunately it worked on me. $300 for a single $21 bottle of wine. They should spend less time writing insincere responses and more time making sure their prices represent fair value.

Agree with most reviewers- this is a… Agree with most reviewers- this is a lousy business. Shipping policy lousy, state they wills sent “free gift”. That doesn’t come. Policy is clear - no returns and their prices are ridiculous. Don’t have anyone else to blame - I ordered thinking the person who requested it had researched. It was my bad that I paid 4 times the cost of the actual product! Lessened learned for me but I hope no one else buys from this overpriced on line marketing scheme.